Although, compared with today, life in the 1880's was leisurely, the supporters of the new church moved quickly.  The meeting at which the church was proposed was held early in 1882 and in October of that same year, the ceremony of the laying of the  foundation stone took place.

As with many aspects of the early days of the new church, written evidence of this occasion in non-existent, however fifty years later a reasonable account of the great day was compiled from personal memories.

 We know for instance that the weather was not very kind when the procession moved off from the mother church of St Mary the virgin. One item of special note on this occasion was the wearing of surplices by the choir, it is understood that this was the first time the choir in Bulwell had worn such garments. On arrival at the site the stone was blessed by Bishop Trollope, suffragan of Lincoln and ceremonially laid by his grace the Duke of Portland.

 The building work duly got underway, the church being built of locally quarried stone in a copy of the early English style of architecture but considerable delay was caused when early one morning the structure above the chancel arch proved too heavy. The supporting pillars collapsed and the masonry came crashing to the ground. Fortunately the workmen had not started their labours that day and so no one was injured. The design was modified and the work was sufficiently advanced for the consecration to take place on Thursday 9th April 1885.

 During the course of this research much debate has centred on the actual centenary date, both 1982 and 1990 being suggested however the consecration date is 9th April 1885.

By the time of the consecration, the Diocese of Southwell had been formed and the previous links with Lincoln severed and so the act of consecration was performed by the first Bishop of Southwell, Dr Ridding, who also administered the sacrament of confirmation in the afternoon. The preacher at Evensong was Canon Hole, afterwards Dean of Rochester and the total collections of the three services held that first day added up to the then immense sum of £297. 1s 4d. The level of giving was not maintained however with collections during 1886 varying between 5s 5d and £1 15s 0d even on occasion dropping to as little as 2s 11d. If these amounts seem ludicrously low nowadays it must be remembered that expenses were correspondingly low.

The earliest recorded baptism took place on May 27th 1866 and is worthy of mention if only for the fact that Samuel and Anne Durose of Adelade street had baptised no fewer than 7 members of their family. The Church was completed on St. James' Day, 1890 and Reverend Cantrell saw the fulfilment of his dream, though he died in September of the same year. The complete cost of the building amounted to £5,000. In memory of her husband, Mrs Cantrell donated the five beautiful coloured east windows, and also placed the alabaster tablet in the chancel.

 In 1902 a set of choir stalls were installed and dedicated to the memory of Reverend Henry Fountain. The reason for this memorial being placed in St John's is not clear. It can only be assumed that stalls were needed and as St. Johns was still the Chapel of Ease to the Mother Church, the opportunity to provide a memorial was taken. Fountain himself never had any direct connection with St John's church although he was a very popular curate of Bulwell until 1808 when he moved to Sutton Bridge Linconshire and remained as vicar of that parish until his death in 1901.